Arent Fox Files US Supreme Court Amicus Brief in Important Civil Liberties Case

Washington, DC — On April 21, Thor Hearne and Stephen S. Davis of Arent Fox LLP filed an amicus brief before the US Supreme Court in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Pauley on behalf of the National Association of Evangelicals.

In part, they argued federal courts should avoid deciding novel issues of state law without first allowing Missouri courts to resolve the issue. This case will determine whether a church can be excluded as the recipient of a non-sectarian non-religious government program simply because it is a religious organization. 

Missouri recycles discarded tires as rubber pellets. This program eliminates old tires from Missouri landfills and makes school playgrounds safer. Trinity Lutheran Church runs a preschool and applied to participate, but the Missouri Department of Natural Resources denied that request, citing a Missouri Constitution provision (the Blaine Amendment) that forbids aid to religious institutions. The Blaine Amendment dates from the late 1800s and contains two critical provisions: the first prevents any discrimination against religious institutions and the second prohibits state aid to religious institutions. The constitutions of dozens of states contain Blaine Amendments, named for James G. Blaine, a speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives in 1875.

“Because no Missouri court has ever interpreted this important provision of our state constitution, principles of federalism require federal courts to abstain and allow the Missouri state court to provide the first interpretation,” said Mr. Hearne. “We are asking the Supreme Court to allow Missouri courts to first rule on the meaning of this provision of the state’s constitution.”

Should the Supreme Court rule upon the constitutionality of Missouri’s Blaine Amendment, Hearne argued the proper understanding of the prohibition against state aid to religious institutions is a prohibition against aid furthering the institution’s sectarian purpose. Neutral non-religious aid, such as rubber pellets for a playground, is not prohibited. Mr. Hearne explained, “If Missouri’s constitution prohibits the State from providing rubber pellets to make safer playgrounds, it would likewise prohibit the fire department from responding when a church caught fire. The notion makes no sense.”

Arent Fox’s Appellate group has earned a reputation for aggressively and effectively managing high-stakes, precedent-setting appeals that protect our clients’ interests. Our goal with every case is to devise the most successful and innovative appellate strategy for clients facing complex legal and business challenges.

About Arent Fox
Founded in 1942, Arent Fox is internationally recognized in core practice areas where business and the law intersect. With more than 400 lawyers, the firm provides strategic legal counsel and multidisciplinary solutions to a global roster of corporations, governments, and trade associations. The firm has offices in Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco, and Washington, DC.


Continue Reading